Best to Beware When Moving to Barefoot Shoes

Santa Clara University student Sandy Nguyen explores what Five Finger shoes - and others - may mean if a runner heads in that direction.

by Sandy Nguyen

You’ve seen those funky foot-glove Vibram Five Finger shoes selling out, Born to Run on display in bookstores, and more and more runners hitting the track without running shoes. But hold onto those sneakers: Abruptly adopting a running form that is foreign to your normal stride can be just as dangerous as running with poor form in regular running shoes.

“We understand the science behind it, but are very cautious by the way we position it with customers,” said Chris Schenone, who founded the specialty store Running Revolution with his brother, Tim. Their stores in Campbell and Santa Cruz have been selling Vibram barefoot shoes and several minimalist models since they first came out. Yet he presses runners to do more research about the technique before wholly embracing it.

Books, magazines, science journals, and newspapers claim that running barefoot or in minimalist shoes – lightweight shoes with less arch support than traditional running shoes – protects runners. Bulky modern running shoes, the theory goes, have altered our natural gait by forcing us to run heel-to-toe, which tends to cause impact-related injuries. The hips, back, and knees are especially vulnerable. If you ditch the shoes, you can run more naturally, according to enthusiasts.

Barefoot runners strike the ground with the front or middle of their foot instead of landing heel to toe, according to research by Daniel Lieberman, professor of human evolutionary biology at Harvard University. This does help protect against impact-related injuries. And because this type of injury is very common, many people immediately want to adopt the technique – running with a light stride, pitter-pattering on the balls of their feet. The idea is simple, but running specialists, podiatrists, medical exercise specialists, and experienced barefoot runners alike encourage new barefoot runners to gain strength first through a slow, methodical, and progressive transition.

Amy LaPine is barefoot runner from Los Gatos, CA who has embraced the new style for the past three years. She’s been a runner for more than twenty years. At one point, she trained for the Olympics. For her, it was obvious to go slow, despite her excitement about her new Vibrams. LaPine did not start barefoot running in earnest for a full year until she was able to comfortably walk in her barefoot shoes. “Barefoot running is a skill and it requires a significant change as well as patience on the part of the runner,” she said.

"Every person runs differently depending on the shoes they normally wear, the way they land on their feet, and their overall form," explained Tim Schenone. These characteristics all affect the time it takes to successfully transition. For instance, an experienced runner who has worn bulky and supportive running shoes his entire life would require more training and a longer transition into barefoot running than a person who already walks barefoot as much as possible. Schenone, who once tore his Achilles tendon (which attaches the calf to the heel), is passionate about cautioning people to take careful and progressive steps toward the new running form. “Start with something manageable," he suggested. "Study it, and work it into your natural gait.”

Even if running barefoot reduces some injuries, it may cause other types of harm. Because minimalist shoes require forefoot or mid-foot striking, the vertical load of our bodies – the force with which your foot hits the ground – can strain several parts of the feet.  Dr. Douglas Robinson, a podiatrist located in Campbell, works with quite a few patients who have hurt themselves while running in minimalist shoes. Many have suffered stress fractures of their lesser metatarsals – the long bones that make up the arch of the foot.  Robinson has also seen issues with Achilles tendons and sesamoids – the small bones that make up the forefoot -- and capsulitis, an inflammation of the joints where the toes meet the metatarsals.

Robinson feels barefoot running has a great deal of potential. In particular, he said, runners with knee, lower back, or hip injuries have benefitted from the technique because of the lighter stride involved. “As a training tool, there are real benefits," Robinson said.  But he suggests starting slow on forgiving terrain, a treadmill, grass, or a track-like surface. "To get out from the get-go and say ‘I’m a barefoot minimalist,’ I think they could really subject themselves to unnecessary harm,” he said.

"Runners should gradually build strength in the feet and calf muscles," said Chris Hallford, a certified medical exercise specialist. He encourages new barefoot runners start out little by little and build up a tolerance. “Walking in the sand and dirt with no shoes at all is a great start to strengthening the proper muscles needed for barefoot running,” he said.

LaPine also advises making small changes in walking patterns throughout the day, such as going barefoot around the house or out on a field for fifteen minutes a day. Ligaments, tendons and muscles need time to strengthen, stretch, and adjust to the new form. This is particularly important for runners who have habitually run heel-to-toe in supportive shoes. They will use different parts of their legs and feet when walking or running barefoot.

Through gradual training, LaPine said, she has greatly benefitted from her transition to barefoot running. She now prefers to leave her regular running shoes in the closet. "One run in my regular shoes, my knee pain came back and my calf muscles were not engaging in the same way,” she recalled.

With patience, anyone can eventually enjoy the benefits of barefoot running, specialists insisted. “Your body will adapt, it just takes time,” said Tim Schenone.

Sandy Nguyen is a student at Santa Clara University. She produced this piece as part of a journalism class taught by Sally Lehrman and as part of a collaborative project with Patch on science in Silicon Valley.

Larry Arzie July 27, 2012 at 11:34 PM
During the summers of love days, running barefoot was the in thing. I ran cross country without support shoes or for that matter almost nude. The coach made us walk around school all day on the ball of our feet to build strength. If we were caught not doing this it would mean 10 more laps. In those days our football coach was Bill Walsh. He and his team would laugh at us for running like ballet dancers. As it turned out we won most every race. HE on the otherhand never won a game in the two years he was there. He was a lousy High School coach. The only problem we had running bare foot was stepping on pebbles but our feet soon turned to leather. My senior year Walsh insisted I join the football team because of my running ability. We still never won a game because as right end I always dropped the ball. He named me footsteps Arzie, because I would drop the ball for fear of being tackled. In football shoes I ran slower, but he refused to allow me to run bare.
Sheila Sanchez July 28, 2012 at 12:03 AM
Hi Larry, thanks for sharing this wonderful memory of your youth. I just know the Kenyans train without shoes at young ages and during my marathon years, no longer running due to an injury, I saw many without shoes and wearing the ones that are the subject of this story. When I told my Educadorian mother that I pay $125 for the Cadillac of running shoes, the Hurricane/Saucony, she about died and called it a waste of good U.S. dollars and said/asked: 'Porque no corres sin zapatos y me das la plata?' LOL Translation: run barefoot and give me the money!
Maria Grusauskas July 28, 2012 at 12:13 AM
Haha! ten more laps if you weren't barefoot on the balls of your feet? That sounds like some harsh coaching..
Maria Grusauskas July 28, 2012 at 12:14 AM
Cadallic of running shoes.. thanks for sharing that one too. se.. me.. hizo.. reir!!
Daniel Anderson August 06, 2012 at 04:42 AM
An insightful article that brings to light in a succinct way the dangers of suddenly switching to 'barefoot' running. More lay people need to improve their knowledge before they go running. Thanks for highlighting that caution and gradual transition is key.


More »
Got a question? Something on your mind? Talk to your community, directly.
Note Article
Just a short thought to get the word out quickly about anything in your neighborhood.
Share something with your neighbors.What's on your mind?What's on your mind?Make an announcement, speak your mind, or sell somethingPost something
See more »